Who Is Your Most Underrated and Overrated Wrestler Ever from Any Company
Options
Idiopathic Joker
Members, Moderators Posts: 45,691 Regulator
Underrated - Shelton Benjamin. Great ring work, extremely athletic, probably could have been a great babyface if WWE wasn't racist.
Overrated - Shawn Michaels. This man is no where near the man WWE tell you he is. Average in ring ability, ok babyface, great heel, I never saw what was so special about this guy.
Overrated - Shawn Michaels. This man is no where near the man WWE tell you he is. Average in ring ability, ok babyface, great heel, I never saw what was so special about this guy.
Comments
-
Overrated: Randy Orton, John Cena, Rob Van Dam, Rey Mysterio, HHH, Jeff Jarrett, Jeff Hardy (tie)
Underrated: Can't think of anyone off the top of my head. Bam Bam Bigalow maybe? -
Underrated-
Sabu
Sandman
Mikey Whipwreck
2 Cold Scorpio
Scorpio Sky(Harold from the Angry management skits)
Lance Strom
Jerry Lynn
Kid Kash
William Regal
Overrated-
John Cena
Randy Orton
Alberto Del Rio
Sheamus
Great Khali
Jinder Mahal
-
cant believe ive seen shawn micheals jeff hardy and rob van dam on an overrated list!!!
overrated: Antonio Cesaro(maybe he was better in roh, but i havent seen it yet), HHH, Kane, Rey Mysterio, Del Rio, Jack Swagger, Khali, Mark Henry, Scott Steiner, Jeff Jarrett, Kevin Nash, Hulk Hogan, Hulk Hogan, Hulk Hogan, Hulk Hogan, Hulk HOgan,
underrated: have to totally agree with genocide minus Steven Regal, plus Shelton Benjamin, Christian, Nova, The Miz, Kofi Kingston, Christopher Daniels, C.W. Anderson, Juventud Guerrera, Raven, Cody Rhodes, AJ Styles, Samoa Joe, D-Lo Brown, Matt Hardy, Shane Helms, Shannon Moore
ill think of more later -
HHH overrated????????
-
deep down in my heart, i think he'd only be a 2 or 3 time champ if not for ? the boss's daughter and being hbk's buddy
-
I would say any wrestler that is able to compete in MMA would be underrated
-
I always thought Big Show was....somewhat underrated, but underpushed more than anything. Dude is (billed at) 7 feet 500 pounds, has a finishing move where he throws one punch a knocks u out cold?? By that logic he should be undefeated and going on his like 10th consecutive year as WWE Champion.
But for some reason his career has always gone, unstoppable monster heel squashing or beating up some little guys then he actually fights a main eventer and gets beat easily. Then gets put in a comedy mid-card babyface gimmick for a while, leaves the company, comes back and repeat. He couldve been undertaker status if wcw or wwe pushed him correctly.
overrated - (Could apply to a lot of people) The indy guy that everybody loves and thinks is the best wrestler alive until he gets called up to a major promotion and has to water down his style then everybody hates him. -
I always thought Big Show was....somewhat underrated, but underpushed more than anything. Dude is (billed at) 7 feet 500 pounds, has a finishing move where he throws one punch a knocks u out cold?? By that logic he should be undefeated and going on his like 10th consecutive year as WWE Champion.
But for some reason his career has always gone, unstoppable monster heel squashing or beating up some little guys then he actually fights a main eventer and gets beat easily. Then gets put in a comedy mid-card babyface gimmick for a while, leaves the company, comes back and repeat. He couldve been undertaker status if wcw or wwe pushed him correctly.
overrated - (Could apply to a lot of people) The indy guy that everybody loves and thinks is the best wrestler alive until he gets called up to a major promotion and has to water down his style then everybody hates him.
wwe released a documentary on the big show years ago. in it show admitted he never had the work ethic. he took his height, weight, and strength for granted so he never worked out. thats how dude started to get fat. if im not mistaking, wwe sent show back to development because of it. thats why he was absent for most of 2000
its a backstage rumor that show called taker a has-been. taker replied "i rather be a has-been than a giant that never was".
and khali is overrated? who the hell said he was something special? -
Big Show is the definition of wasted talent
-
Already Home_17 wrote: »I always thought Big Show was....somewhat underrated, but underpushed more than anything. Dude is (billed at) 7 feet 500 pounds, has a finishing move where he throws one punch a knocks u out cold?? By that logic he should be undefeated and going on his like 10th consecutive year as WWE Champion.
But for some reason his career has always gone, unstoppable monster heel squashing or beating up some little guys then he actually fights a main eventer and gets beat easily. Then gets put in a comedy mid-card babyface gimmick for a while, leaves the company, comes back and repeat. He couldve been undertaker status if wcw or wwe pushed him correctly.
overrated - (Could apply to a lot of people) The indy guy that everybody loves and thinks is the best wrestler alive until he gets called up to a major promotion and has to water down his style then everybody hates him.
wwe released a documentary on the big show years ago. in it show admitted he never had the work ethic. he took his height, weight, and strength for granted so he never worked out. thats how dude started to get fat. if im not mistaking, wwe sent show back to development because of it. thats why he was absent for most of 2000
its a backstage rumor that show called taker a has-been. taker replied "i rather be a has-been than a giant that never was".
and khali is overrated? who the hell said he was something special?
That ether, that ? that make your soul burn slow -
Already Home_17 wrote: »I always thought Big Show was....somewhat underrated, but underpushed more than anything. Dude is (billed at) 7 feet 500 pounds, has a finishing move where he throws one punch a knocks u out cold?? By that logic he should be undefeated and going on his like 10th consecutive year as WWE Champion.
But for some reason his career has always gone, unstoppable monster heel squashing or beating up some little guys then he actually fights a main eventer and gets beat easily. Then gets put in a comedy mid-card babyface gimmick for a while, leaves the company, comes back and repeat. He couldve been undertaker status if wcw or wwe pushed him correctly.
overrated - (Could apply to a lot of people) The indy guy that everybody loves and thinks is the best wrestler alive until he gets called up to a major promotion and has to water down his style then everybody hates him.
wwe released a documentary on the big show years ago. in it show admitted he never had the work ethic. he took his height, weight, and strength for granted so he never worked out. thats how dude started to get fat. if im not mistaking, wwe sent show back to development because of it. thats why he was absent for most of 2000
its a backstage rumor that show called taker a has-been. taker replied "i rather be a has-been than a giant that never was".
and khali is overrated? who the hell said he was something special?
for some reason wwe thought he was something special enough for a main event title push
-
Shawn Michaels overrated huh?? SMH
I keep saying this but Rob Van Damn is the most overrated wrestler of all time... -
Cutler 26 INT's LOL! wrote: »Shawn Michaels overrated huh?? SMH
I keep saying this but Rob Van Damn is the most overrated wrestler of all time...
Shawn Michaels is average at best. Vince Mcmahon hypes him up so everyone believes it
-
Sheldon Benjamin was underrated his skill set was so versatile he could slam people (dat german suplex nd Oklahoma slam was mean), he could do flips off da top ropes nd turnbuckle he wasnt used enough
Overrated- Randy Orton, Dolph Ziggler wack move sets nd even worse finishers -
Cutler 26 INT's LOL! wrote: »Cutler 26 INT's LOL! wrote: »Shawn Michaels overrated huh?? SMH
I keep saying this but Rob Van Damn is the most overrated wrestler of all time...
Naw homie, ECW days/early WWE days RVD was that dude. -
wouldnt say shawn is overrated but he aint GOAT as Vince and alot of ? make him seem
-
shawn michaels was given the name showstopper for a reason. he's a great performer and liable to steal the show everytime he performed. look at his track-record at WM alone since he returned in 02
WM19- vs. jericho
WM20 - vs. hhh and benoit
WM21 - vs. angle
WM22 - vs. mcmahon *not the match of the night but it had some great spots*
WM23 - vs. cena
WM24 - vs. flair
WM25 and 26 - vs. taker
he arguably had the best match at these events and he wasnt even in his prime -
Already Home_17 wrote: »shawn michaels was given the name showstopper for a reason. he's a great performer and liable to steal the show everytime he performed. look at his track-record at WM alone since he returned in 02
WM19- vs. jericho
WM20 - vs. hhh and benoit
WM21 - vs. angle
WM22 - vs. mcmahon *not the match of the night but it had some great spots*
WM23 - vs. cena
WM24 - vs. flair
WM25 and 26 - vs. taker
he arguably had the best match at these events and he wasnt even in his prime
WM19 - a classic
WM20 - all hhh and benoit
WM21 - wack
WM23 - ok at best
WM24 - terrible to watch. his im sorry and i love you to flair were corny as hell. not the match of the night
WM25 - A decent match in a terrible ppv
WM26 - boring
like I said overrated
-
The_Maryvale_Joker wrote: »Already Home_17 wrote: »shawn michaels was given the name showstopper for a reason. he's a great performer and liable to steal the show everytime he performed. look at his track-record at WM alone since he returned in 02
WM19- vs. jericho
WM20 - vs. hhh and benoit
WM21 - vs. angle
WM22 - vs. mcmahon *not the match of the night but it had some great spots*
WM23 - vs. cena
WM24 - vs. flair
WM25 and 26 - vs. taker
he arguably had the best match at these events and he wasnt even in his prime
WM19 - a classic
WM20 - all hhh and benoit
WM21 - wack
WM23 - ok at best
WM24 - terrible to watch. his im sorry and i love you to flair were corny as hell. not the match of the night
WM25 - A decent match in a terrible ppv
WM26 - boring
like I said overrated
hmm, ok. i see where you're coming from........
-
The_Maryvale_Joker wrote: »Already Home_17 wrote: »shawn michaels was given the name showstopper for a reason. he's a great performer and liable to steal the show everytime he performed. look at his track-record at WM alone since he returned in 02
WM19- vs. jericho
WM20 - vs. hhh and benoit
WM21 - vs. angle
WM22 - vs. mcmahon *not the match of the night but it had some great spots*
WM23 - vs. cena
WM24 - vs. flair
WM25 and 26 - vs. taker
he arguably had the best match at these events and he wasnt even in his prime
WM19 - a classic
WM20 - all hhh and benoit
WM21 - wack
WM23 - ok at best
WM24 - terrible to watch. his im sorry and i love you to flair were corny as hell. not the match of the night
WM25 - A decent match in a terrible ppv
WM26 - boring
like I said overrated
u trippin mane -
@Peezy_Jenkins: Cesaro wasnt that exciting in ROH, but take Chikara, PWG and even CZW now and then we're talking.
John Cena: I get it, he is over. As in overrated. Without bashing the guy, his punches still looks weaker than RVD's (which is saying something).
Not as much underrated as underutilised: Ted DeBiase. -
Wrestlemania 21 with Angle was wack?!
Yea mane stop trollin...we get it... -
Cutler 26 INT's LOL! wrote: »Wrestlemania 21 with Angle was wack?!
Yea mane stop trollin...we get it...
I'm trolling, but you saying RVD is overrated -
HBK is the GOAT. Nobody has had more classic matches and been more innovated and appeared in more innovated matches than HBGoat
-
Overrated: CM Punk - He's not a bad wrestler and his mic skills are good, but I feel he's overrated. He's the Lil' Wayne of wrestling, he calls himself the best and people believe it because there isn't much competition out there.
John Cena - He seems like a good guy but this guy is everything wrong with wrestling right now. A mediocre wrestler with corny PG jokes and sub-par mic skills. The PG jokes I can excuse cuz we all know WWE is catered to a younger audience, but his promos would still be wack even if he came up in the Attitude Era. But I give him credit for having this type of career despite the things I said about him.
Underrated: Ahmed Johnson, Vader, 1-2-3 Kid or X-Pac, Marc Mero and Bob Holly
