Marvin Gaye Family Wins First Legal Battle Against Robin Thicke, Pharrell, & T.I.

124»

Comments

  • THIRDSUPREME
    THIRDSUPREME Members Posts: 7,519 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Go ahead and make a hook with the exact melody of in the club but different lyrics and see if you don't get sued if it becomes a hit. You can't steal peoples ideas....thats ? ? . Just pay the clearance fee.
  • LUClEN
    LUClEN Members Posts: 20,559 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Go ahead and make a hook with the exact melody of in the club but different lyrics and see if you don't get sued if it becomes a hit. You can't steal peoples ideas....thats ? ? . Just pay the clearance fee.

    it's not the same melody
    your comparison does not fit

    He did not even use the same scale
    how could it be the same melody?
  • Swiffness!
    Swiffness! Members Posts: 10,128 ✭✭✭✭✭
    a.mann wrote: »
    Personal opinions and racial animosity aside

    This isn't really a "good" thing

    this

    ? copywriting rhythm
  • T. Sanford
    T. Sanford Guests, Members, Writer, Content Producer Posts: 25,291 ✭✭✭✭✭
    If he would have got a Nitti beat then this wouldn't happen
  • StillFaggyAF
    StillFaggyAF Members Posts: 40,358 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Trashboat wrote: »
    Go ahead and make a hook with the exact melody of in the club but different lyrics and see if you don't get sued if it becomes a hit. You can't steal peoples ideas....thats ? ? . Just pay the clearance fee.

    it's not the same melody
    your comparison does not fit

    He did not even use the same scale
    how could it be the same melody
    ?

    you guys who dont know anything about music should just stop
  • LUClEN
    LUClEN Members Posts: 20,559 ✭✭✭✭✭
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    Go ahead and make a hook with the exact melody of in the club but different lyrics and see if you don't get sued if it becomes a hit. You can't steal peoples ideas....thats ? ? . Just pay the clearance fee.

    it's not the same melody
    your comparison does not fit

    He did not even use the same scale
    how could it be the same melody
    ?

    you guys who dont know anything about music should just stop

    So answer the question then

    Instead of answering it you ? foot around the question
    Step up or shut up
  • StillFaggyAF
    StillFaggyAF Members Posts: 40,358 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    Go ahead and make a hook with the exact melody of in the club but different lyrics and see if you don't get sued if it becomes a hit. You can't steal peoples ideas....thats ? ? . Just pay the clearance fee.

    it's not the same melody
    your comparison does not fit

    He did not even use the same scale
    how could it be the same melody
    ?

    you guys who dont know anything about music should just stop

    So answer the question then

    Instead of answering it you ? foot around the question
    Step up or shut up

    ooh you got some testosterone in your posts now


    melodies have nothing to do with scales, i can play "Mary Had a Little Lamb" across the circle of fifths and it will still be "Mary Had A Little Lamb"
  • LUClEN
    LUClEN Members Posts: 20,559 ✭✭✭✭✭
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    Go ahead and make a hook with the exact melody of in the club but different lyrics and see if you don't get sued if it becomes a hit. You can't steal peoples ideas....thats ? ? . Just pay the clearance fee.

    it's not the same melody
    your comparison does not fit

    He did not even use the same scale
    how could it be the same melody
    ?

    you guys who dont know anything about music should just stop

    So answer the question then

    Instead of answering it you ? foot around the question
    Step up or shut up

    ooh you got some testosterone in your posts now


    melodies have nothing to do with scales, i can play "Mary Had a Little Lamb" across the circle of fifths and it will still be "Mary Had A Little Lamb"

    Melodies do involve scales
    when comparing the sheet music they will look different because they involve different notes

  • StillFaggyAF
    StillFaggyAF Members Posts: 40,358 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    Go ahead and make a hook with the exact melody of in the club but different lyrics and see if you don't get sued if it becomes a hit. You can't steal peoples ideas....thats ? ? . Just pay the clearance fee.

    it's not the same melody
    your comparison does not fit

    He did not even use the same scale
    how could it be the same melody
    ?

    you guys who dont know anything about music should just stop

    So answer the question then

    Instead of answering it you ? foot around the question
    Step up or shut up

    ooh you got some testosterone in your posts now


    melodies have nothing to do with scales, i can play "Mary Had a Little Lamb" across the circle of fifths and it will still be "Mary Had A Little Lamb"

    Melodies do involve scales
    when comparing the sheet music they will look different because they involve different notes

    Melody predates sheet music and paper itself so gtfoh amd go learn some baisc theory
  • LUClEN
    LUClEN Members Posts: 20,559 ✭✭✭✭✭
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    Go ahead and make a hook with the exact melody of in the club but different lyrics and see if you don't get sued if it becomes a hit. You can't steal peoples ideas....thats ? ? . Just pay the clearance fee.

    it's not the same melody
    your comparison does not fit

    He did not even use the same scale
    how could it be the same melody
    ?

    you guys who dont know anything about music should just stop

    So answer the question then

    Instead of answering it you ? foot around the question
    Step up or shut up

    ooh you got some testosterone in your posts now


    melodies have nothing to do with scales, i can play "Mary Had a Little Lamb" across the circle of fifths and it will still be "Mary Had A Little Lamb"

    Melodies do involve scales
    when comparing the sheet music they will look different because they involve different notes

    Melody predates sheet music and paper itself so gtfoh amd go learn some baisc theory

    That's irrelevant to the case
    This case is going to be decided by the sheet music, not feelings
  • StillFaggyAF
    StillFaggyAF Members Posts: 40,358 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    Go ahead and make a hook with the exact melody of in the club but different lyrics and see if you don't get sued if it becomes a hit. You can't steal peoples ideas....thats ? ? . Just pay the clearance fee.

    it's not the same melody
    your comparison does not fit

    He did not even use the same scale
    how could it be the same melody
    ?

    you guys who dont know anything about music should just stop

    So answer the question then

    Instead of answering it you ? foot around the question
    Step up or shut up

    ooh you got some testosterone in your posts now


    melodies have nothing to do with scales, i can play "Mary Had a Little Lamb" across the circle of fifths and it will still be "Mary Had A Little Lamb"

    Melodies do involve scales
    when comparing the sheet music they will look different because they involve different notes

    Melody predates sheet music and paper itself so gtfoh amd go learn some baisc theory

    That's irrelevant to the case
    This case is going to be decided by the sheet music, not feelings

    You made an incorrect statement, i corrected you. Get mad
  • LUClEN
    LUClEN Members Posts: 20,559 ✭✭✭✭✭
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    Go ahead and make a hook with the exact melody of in the club but different lyrics and see if you don't get sued if it becomes a hit. You can't steal peoples ideas....thats ? ? . Just pay the clearance fee.

    it's not the same melody
    your comparison does not fit

    He did not even use the same scale
    how could it be the same melody
    ?

    you guys who dont know anything about music should just stop

    So answer the question then

    Instead of answering it you ? foot around the question
    Step up or shut up

    ooh you got some testosterone in your posts now


    melodies have nothing to do with scales, i can play "Mary Had a Little Lamb" across the circle of fifths and it will still be "Mary Had A Little Lamb"

    Melodies do involve scales
    when comparing the sheet music they will look different because they involve different notes

    Melody predates sheet music and paper itself so gtfoh amd go learn some baisc theory

    That's irrelevant to the case
    This case is going to be decided by the sheet music, not feelings

    You made an incorrect statement, i corrected you. Get mad

    You corrected nothing

    The melody was alleged to be the same but the notes are not even the same
    That mary had a litlte lamb compairosn is a complete false equivalence because those songs would be played in the same time

    None of that is applicable here

    Looking at the sheet music the melodies are not the same at all
    the percussion is not similar nor are the bass lines
  • StillFaggyAF
    StillFaggyAF Members Posts: 40,358 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    Go ahead and make a hook with the exact melody of in the club but different lyrics and see if you don't get sued if it becomes a hit. You can't steal peoples ideas....thats ? ? . Just pay the clearance fee.

    it's not the same melody
    your comparison does not fit

    He did not even use the same scale
    how could it be the same melody
    ?

    you guys who dont know anything about music should just stop

    So answer the question then

    Instead of answering it you ? foot around the question
    Step up or shut up

    ooh you got some testosterone in your posts now


    melodies have nothing to do with scales, i can play "Mary Had a Little Lamb" across the circle of fifths and it will still be "Mary Had A Little Lamb"

    Melodies do involve scales
    when comparing the sheet music they will look different because they involve different notes

    Melody predates sheet music and paper itself so gtfoh amd go learn some baisc theory

    That's irrelevant to the case
    This case is going to be decided by the sheet music, not feelings

    You made an incorrect statement, i corrected you. Get mad

    You corrected nothing

    The melody was alleged to be the same but the notes are not even the same
    That mary had a litlte lamb compairosn is a complete false equivalence because those songs would be played in the same time

    None of that is applicable here

    Looking at the sheet music the melodies are not the same at all
    the percussion is not similar nor are the bass lines

    You mad as ? stick to regurgitating your professors and leave music alone
  • LUClEN
    LUClEN Members Posts: 20,559 ✭✭✭✭✭
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    AggyAF wrote: »
    Trashboat wrote: »
    Go ahead and make a hook with the exact melody of in the club but different lyrics and see if you don't get sued if it becomes a hit. You can't steal peoples ideas....thats ? ? . Just pay the clearance fee.

    it's not the same melody
    your comparison does not fit

    He did not even use the same scale
    how could it be the same melody
    ?

    you guys who dont know anything about music should just stop

    So answer the question then

    Instead of answering it you ? foot around the question
    Step up or shut up

    ooh you got some testosterone in your posts now


    melodies have nothing to do with scales, i can play "Mary Had a Little Lamb" across the circle of fifths and it will still be "Mary Had A Little Lamb"

    Melodies do involve scales
    when comparing the sheet music they will look different because they involve different notes

    Melody predates sheet music and paper itself so gtfoh amd go learn some baisc theory

    That's irrelevant to the case
    This case is going to be decided by the sheet music, not feelings

    You made an incorrect statement, i corrected you. Get mad

    You corrected nothing

    The melody was alleged to be the same but the notes are not even the same
    That mary had a litlte lamb compairosn is a complete false equivalence because those songs would be played in the same time

    None of that is applicable here

    Looking at the sheet music the melodies are not the same at all
    the percussion is not similar nor are the bass lines

    You mad as ? stick to regurgitating your professors and leave music alone

    I'm not mad at all

    The Gaye estate has no case