Better Overall NBA Player: Paul Pierce or Vince Carter or T-Mac
DOPEdweebz
Members, Moderators, Writer Posts: 29,364 Regulator
Just added T-Mac to make this a bit more interesting
Better Overall NBA Player: Paul Pierce or Vince Carter or T-Mac 62 votes
Comments
-
There needs to be clarification when 'better player' is brought up:
Half the people base it on historically
The other half base it who is more talented and has the best 'game'
Historically its Pierce, best actual baller was TMac -
Tracy McGradyTo me
Greatness is of what's accomplished, legacy. A duration of a career.
Better is on their best day skillset to skillset who's the better player. -
? ? me all up didnt even see Tmac till i opened the thread
-
Paul PierceWhen I factor in longevity and skill I have to go with pierce
-
Tracy McGradyvince is my favorite of em all
if im thinking like who was the best at their respective peak my order is
tmac
vince
paul pierce
of course people will say pierce lasted longer but im not thinking overall career/longevity. -
There needs to be clarification when 'better player' is brought up:
Half the people base it on historically
The other half base it who is more talented and has the best 'game'
Historically its Pierce, best actual baller was TMac
I purposely left that and their "peaks" out and let people base their opinions on their own standards like we do for every other player or athlete. -
Paul PierceThe Truth
-
Paul PierceI don't know how anyone picked Carter or T-Mac over Pierce. The man almost made the Damn ECF this year
-
Tracy McGradyTMac was the better player.
Pierce has had a better career -
-
Tracy McGradyMac got overshadowed for a second because the Magic were trash in his prime when he was there. His career would have looked better if Grant Hill had been healthy and the team was better. He was top 5 in the league for a minute, though.
-
Lmaooo he was too 5 in the league at one point ??
? he was top 1 for a minute -
Paul PierceLol @ the one Carter vote
-
Tracy McGradyVince Carter in the best shape though
-
Tracy McGrady^today
-
Tracy McGrady^today
-
There needs to be clarification when 'better player' is brought up:
Half the people base it on historically
The other half base it who is more talented and has the best 'game'
Historically its Pierce, best actual baller was TMac
Came to post something similar. No need now! -
Paul PierceLmaooo he was too 5 in the league at one point ??
? he was top 1 for a minute
Top 5 is being generous enough, stop it -
Paul PierceLmaooo he was too 5 in the league at one point ??
? he was top 1 for a minute
Top 5 is being generous enough, stop it -
its....JOHN B wrote: »
What -
-
its....JOHN B wrote: »
Ehhhh you're entitled to believe what you want even if it is basura -
Breezy_Kilroy wrote: »TMac was the better player.
Pierce has had a better career
Quoted for emphasis -
Lmaooo he was too 5 in the league at one point ??
? he was top 1 for a minute
Nah him, Kobe, and AI were all hitting their stride around the same time.
He wasted the bulk of his prime with that garbage Orlando squad getting beat out in the first round every year. -
I don't know how anyone picked Carter or T-Mac over Pierce. The man almost made the Damn ECF this year
Did you see his numbers?