Better gimmick: Hell in a Cell vs Elimination Chamber

jono

Which do you think makes for better matches or the better idea?

Peezy_Jenkins

idk, but i kinda feel like "pg" has neutered hiac a lot more than elimination chamber.

vageneral08

Hell in a Cell

Some the best matches were in hell in a cell

Young Gunner

Elimination Chamber

I guess you can do more in the chamber

Delphas

Hell in a Cell

I like the concept of Elimination Chamber more, but HIAC were always executed better.

BeleeDatPleighboy

Hell in a Cell

HIAC has too many iconic moments and matches

Foley off the top of the cell is IMO a top 2 moment in wrestling history.

jono

Hell in a Cell

I love the chamber though. 2005 New Years Revolution was the GOAT eliminatiom chamber match.

Idiopathic Joker

Elimination Chamber

Just barley I have to choose elimination chamber. Better matches quality wise, but some had real ? endings. But hiac had great ? too. I loved cactus jack vs hhh, batista vs hhh, mankind vs taker, and lesnar vs taker.

dalyricalbandit

Hell in the Cell is more Iconic but has lost its aura since WWE gone pg all the insane stuff just doesnt happen anymore.

EC i like the structure more the whole metal floor outside the ropes and the pods

Already Home_17

Hell in a Cell

I remember the sick rattle the steel floor would make when someone fell on it during a chamber match
now that ? doesn't even make a peep

imo hell in a cell matches have been much more memorable and produced greater memories. most chamber matches after 2009 are a blur to me

unfortunately thanks to gimmick based ppv's these matches have lost their luster. but can still be great under the right circumstances

Peezy_Jenkins

the last few years of hiac matches have really hurt it, the roman/bray match recently is prolly the only one that can come close to standing next to vintage hiac matches violence wise, there have still been a couple fun ec matches despite the pg ? imo, tough call

jono

Hell in a Cell

The chamber is a fun concept. They took the rumble and a HIAC match then fused them in a way where its dope. The only problem is there is only so much you can do inside the chamber and going outside of it or on the top is pretty much out of the question.

willhustle

Hell in a Cell

Already Home_17 wrote: »

I remember the sick rattle the steel floor would make when someone fell on it during a chamber match
now that ? doesn't even make a peep

imo hell in a cell matches have been much more memorable and produced greater memories. most chamber matches after 2009 are a blur to me

unfortunately thanks to gimmick based ppv's these matches have lost their luster. but can still be great under the right circumstances

Yeah Vince is running the gimmick PPVs into the ground enough is enough already. They need to get rid of TLC & HIAC especially TLC that ppv is nothing but filler at the end of every year. HIAC is still a good concept match but has been tamed and has lost a lot of luster since WWE went back to a PG format.

dalyricalbandit

Rumble
Mania
King of the Ring
SummerSlam
Survivor Series

And maybe 3 In Your House like ppvs u can run MITB etc.

HITC,Elimination Chamber,extreme Rules,TLC all need to go if u gonna have one of those matches just have it on one of those other ppvs.

dalyricalbandit

Would be dope if they had some WCW theme ppvs

Bash at the beach/great American bash before SummerSlam

World war 3 like a MITB match (Vince has said he hates multiple rings tho)

Starcade after the rumble but before Mania

Peezy_Jenkins

the big 5, plus mitb (big 6) ppvs

and network specials or 3 in your houses like u said, they'd be str8

then it'd be 2 months to build programs, and the network specials would add even more heat n animosity n ? .