Who is/will be the Most successful black QB?
Trillfate
Members Posts: 24,008 ✭✭✭✭✭
Not your favorite, but the one who has/will achieve the most in the NFL
Who is/will be the Most successful black QB? 48 votes
Cam
27%
13 votes
Wilson
18%
9 votes
Vick
2%
1 vote
Mcnabb
12%
6 votes
Culpepper
0%
Cunningham
0%
Moon
33%
16 votes
Doug Williams
4%
2 votes
McNair
0%
other
2%
1 vote
Comments
-
Wilson and Cam no one else really ranks seeing as they are not playing anymore
-
McnabbRight now 1-26-2016
It's McNabb -
WilsonWilson as of now but Cam will eclipse him soon.
-
Moon^^^lol @ Wilson as of now
Wilson and Cam are on PACE to eclipse the greats, but geez at picking them over Moon and McNabb, and to a lesser degreeCunningham
Definitely can't take them over Moon tho, no way. Moon,is a damn,hall of famer, so that easily puts him over Wlliams, Mcnair (kinda overeatee RIP) , and the rest
I hate young mfers,man. No respect for history -
McnabbShizlansky wrote: »Right now 1-26-2016
It's McNabb
Co-sign this. Right now it's McNuggets with a very slim margin over Moon. McNuggets got the numbers, the pedigree in Philly, and almost everything else. The only thing he's missing was that ring.
However, in five years, I except either Cam or Russ - or BOTH - to take that spot. So, unless someone else comes along and slaughter the league like these two are doing, by decade's end, they'll be either 1 & 2, or 1a and 1b. -
I would say McNabb right now, but Cam coming for that. I feel like Wilson's best argument is playoffs n superbowl appereances n they def factor into it all...but his defense n running game were a big reason for him getting there.
-
Yea id say Mcnabb now also but its a wrap.. All these dude have to do is play out the string.. If Mcnabb wasnt such a company man and a sensitive ? he'd have at least a ring on his finger.. There was a time it was him and Manning Imo.
-
CamWill be? Cam close thread
-
Mcnabbplaymaker88 wrote: »Yea id say Mcnabb now also but its a wrap.. All these dude have to do is play out the string.. If Mcnabb wasnt such a company man and a sensitive ? he'd have at least a ring on his finger.. There was a time it was him and Manning Imo.
Now that I think about it im suprised Mcnabb never won league MVP... especially that first year with TO -
-
McnabbThis ? changed the title.
Lock this ? up. -
WilsonDumb thread. Why have presented and past
-
McnabbFolks stay forgetting about McNabb
-
MoonMoon hes the only hall of famer on the list (CFL and Pro Football HOF)
-
CamRg3
-
McnabbShout out Tyrod Taylor... the Bills are committed
-
McNabb had a good career but nothing he did to me made me feel like he was game changing QB. His best year was with TO & that Philly D during that time is underrated.
To me Warren Moon is still the best black QB with Cam & Wilson having the best chances to overtake him. -
MoonMcNabb had a good career but nothing he did to me made me feel like he was game changing QB. His best year was with TO & that Philly D during that time is underrated.
To me Warren Moon is still the best black QB with Cam & Wilson having the best chances to overtake him.
I disagree did u see who he had to throw 2 all those years before he got TO? Trash pinkston Brown Mitchell... mcabb had some of the goat scrambles in the pocket and they won. Dude was a great qb -
MoonMoon was 3rd all time in passing yards. Had he not had to go to Canada he woulds been #1 all time in passing yards over Marino.
-
McNabb had a good career but nothing he did to me made me feel like he was game changing QB. His best year was with TO & that Philly D during that time is underrated.
To me Warren Moon is still the best black QB with Cam & Wilson having the best chances to overtake him.
I disagree did u see who he had to throw 2 all those years before he got TO? Trash pinkston Brown Mitchell... mcabb had some of the goat scrambles in the pocket and they won. Dude was a great qb
Yea he had some sorry WR depth before TO. So did Tom Brady before Moss & he still managed to win three Super Bowls.
McNabb still was a good QB but they should of won at least one Super Bowl. -
McnabbMcNabb had a good career but nothing he did to me made me feel like he was game changing QB. His best year was with TO & that Philly D during that time is underrated.
To me Warren Moon is still the best black QB with Cam & Wilson having the best chances to overtake him.
I disagree did u see who he had to throw 2 all those years before he got TO? Trash pinkston Brown Mitchell... mcabb had some of the goat scrambles in the pocket and they won. Dude was a great qb
Yea he had some sorry WR depth before TO. So did Tom Brady before Moss & he still managed to win three Super Bowls.
McNabb still was a good QB but they should of won at least one Super Bowl.
Brady defense won 3 Superbowls. Their offense wasn't anything great -
Shizlansky wrote: »McNabb had a good career but nothing he did to me made me feel like he was game changing QB. His best year was with TO & that Philly D during that time is underrated.
To me Warren Moon is still the best black QB with Cam & Wilson having the best chances to overtake him.
I disagree did u see who he had to throw 2 all those years before he got TO? Trash pinkston Brown Mitchell... mcabb had some of the goat scrambles in the pocket and they won. Dude was a great qb
Yea he had some sorry WR depth before TO. So did Tom Brady before Moss & he still managed to win three Super Bowls.
McNabb still was a good QB but they should of won at least one Super Bowl.
Brady defense won 3 Superbowls. Their offense wasn't anything great
No they weren't but I basically said what you just did when you quoted me. Brady was clutch when it mattered those Super Bowl years tho. Something McNabb couldn't do & the those offenses before TO came was just as slightly above average.
McNabb & Brady were basically in the same boat. Good QB with average supporting cast & superior defenses. Brady handled it in big moments, McNabb didn't. -
I hate how the league did him coming out of college. There's no way he should've been the MVP of the Rose Bowl and gone undrafted.Moon was 3rd all time in passing yards. Had he not had to go to Canada he woulds been #1 all time in passing yards over Marino. -
CamShizlansky wrote: »McNabb had a good career but nothing he did to me made me feel like he was game changing QB. His best year was with TO & that Philly D during that time is underrated.
To me Warren Moon is still the best black QB with Cam & Wilson having the best chances to overtake him.
I disagree did u see who he had to throw 2 all those years before he got TO? Trash pinkston Brown Mitchell... mcabb had some of the goat scrambles in the pocket and they won. Dude was a great qb
Yea he had some sorry WR depth before TO. So did Tom Brady before Moss & he still managed to win three Super Bowls.
McNabb still was a good QB but they should of won at least one Super Bowl.
Brady defense won 3 Superbowls. Their offense wasn't anything great
No they weren't but I basically said what you just did when you quoted me. Brady was clutch when it mattered those Super Bowl years tho. Something McNabb couldn't do & the those offenses before TO came was just as slightly above average.
McNabb & Brady were basically in the same boat. Good QB with average supporting cast & superior defenses. Brady handled it in big moments, McNabb didn't.
Brady also had Belichick and this was during spy gate. -
Veniteri.(spellcheck) and a great offensive line
