Prime D Wade vs. Prime T Mac: Who is better?
Options
DOPEdweebz
Members, Moderators, Writer Posts: 29,364 Regulator
McGrady's best year was probably 2002:
32.8 PPG, 6.5 Rebs, 5.5. Dimes, 1.7 Steals, .8 Blocks on 45.7% shooting.
Wades was 2008
30.2 PPG 5 Rebs, 7.5 Dimes, 2.2 Steals, 1.3 Blocks on 49.1% Shooting
32.8 PPG, 6.5 Rebs, 5.5. Dimes, 1.7 Steals, .8 Blocks on 45.7% shooting.
Wades was 2008
30.2 PPG 5 Rebs, 7.5 Dimes, 2.2 Steals, 1.3 Blocks on 49.1% Shooting
Prime D Wade vs. Prime T Mac: Who is better? 31 votes
Prime Dwayne Wade
64%
20 votes
Prime Tracy McGrady
35%
11 votes
Comments
-
Man gtfoh with this
-
Prime Dwayne WadeSmh can't even spell wades name right
-
Prime Dwayne WadeSmh can't even spell wades name right
His mama didnt spell his name right -
-
Prime D Wade made it past the first round
-
Prime Dwayne WadeT mac was a loser
-
Prime Tracy McGradyPrime? T-Mac would be too much for Wade to handle. Too long, too tall, too athletic, too skilled.
Who's greater/more decorated? Wade easy.
Better player throughout their career? Wade clearly. -
Prime Tracy McGradyWade is obviously the more accomplished player, has had a tremendous career and is a first ballot hall of famer.......But watching prime T-Mac was like watching a once in a generation type player and was one of the most gifted ball players Ive ever seen, as great as Wade is I never got that feeling watching him
-
The only time dwayne wade took over 20 fga's a game he led the league in scoring he's better than tmac in pretty much everything
Wade a better playmaker,better defender,better closer,better handle,better post game.They were equal scorers when you factor in wade averaged the same numbers as tmac on less shots and had better fg %'s and wade led his team further than tmac ever did in his rookie year.Young/prime wade played just like 84-89 jordan tmac wasn't even the best sg in the league in his prime wade WAS,what are we talkin about. -
Prime Tracy McGradyI dont think its an outlandish argument either way but imo during that time he was the best shooting guard in basketball depending on who you asked, you would also get Kobe, Iverson and Vince Carter....not to mention guys like Ray Allen and Ginobili. These guys are some of the best shooting guards ever.....who in Wades era could be considered an all time great shooting guard?
Only thing I would definitely say Wade was better at was defense,getting to the rim/free throw line, maybe a slightly better passer......TMac was the better shooter, rebounder and ball handler(T-Mac averaged 3 TO per game once, Wade averaged over 4 several times)...everything else is a matter of preference
Wade also played with Caron Butler and pre-? Lamar Odom his rookie year.....T-Mac played with trash majority of his career and definitely his prime Orlando years -
southsil4lil wrote: »I dont think its an outlandish argument either way but imo during that time he was the best shooting guard in basketball depending on who you asked, you would also get Kobe, Iverson and Vince Carter....not to mention guys like Ray Allen and Ginobili. These guys are some of the best shooting guards ever.....who in Wades era could be considered an all time great shooting guard?
Only thing I would definitely say Wade was better at was defense,getting to the rim/free throw line, maybe a slightly better passer......TMac was the better shooter, rebounder and ball handler(T-Mac averaged 3 TO per game once, Wade averaged over 4 several times)...everything else is a matter of preference
Wade also played with Caron Butler and pre-? Lamar Odom his rookie year.....T-Mac played with trash majority of his career and definitely his prime Orlando years
kobe bryant
He should be a better rebounder he is 4 inches taller than wade
Averaging less to's does not mean you're a better ball handler.It means you take care of the ball better.For example curry has a better handle than chris paul,but chris paul takes care of the ball much better and routinely has way less turnovers.I'm going off the eye test not turnover numbers wades handle is better than tmacs he was the primary playmaker for the heat for years cuz of it
You can't post reckless lies like this without backing it up Tmac efg% and ts% are lower than wades in their best seasons tmac never had a better % than wade ever, that's literally how they measure shooting.Wade has better per in their primes too and they're neck in neck in offensive ratings.So basically there's no case for tmac being better unless that's what you prefer personally(of course being a dickriding homer rocket fan that's why)
I agree tmac played with trash in orlando but even wit yao he did nothing
and when he did make the playoffs they were routinely gettin bounced in the 1st round duke was melo before melo -
Prime Tracy McGradyKobe Bryant is Mcgradys era
Still better
I said Wade is the better playmaker but the handles is definitely debatable and perfer T-Mac, I could post a video to refresh your memory of how good he was handling the ball but I know you wont watch it so I wont waste my time
So we can use the eye test for ballhandling but not shooting lol....you know damn well Wade used to live in the paint and freethrow line so of course his true shooting percentage amd efficiency is going to be higher. Wade didnt have a better jumper than T-Mac and damn sure didnt have the range
You dickride a perinnial loser squad like the Clippers and Chris Paul and they made it one round further with way more talent
I dont knock people for picking Wade, hes a top 5 SG and has had an illustrious career.....but I really do think because prime T-Mac was so long ago a lot of people truly dont remember the type of talent he was. -
I use to argue wit cats about kobe vs tmac 13-14 years ago.I know his game
That being said you're done,off topic babbling about the clippers/chris paul in a tmac or wade debate lol nuff said
Lol @ a rockets fan talkin bout losers your wack ass team hasn't won jack since bone thugs n harmony debuted and have lost in the 1st round 3 out the last 4 years.Must be nice callin other teams pretenders
Cheap seats y'all -
Prime Dwayne Wade
-
Prime Tracy McGradylol the way this ? talks you would think the Bulls just won the championship and not the Cubs, Michael Jordan isnt walking through that door just like Hakeem isnt
Shout out to the Bulls missing the playoffs last year though, nice little change up from getting sonned by Lebron every year -
Lebron has been to 6 finals in a row "the bulls getting sonned" retort is played.The whole east been gettin sonned by duke
I saw the bulls win championships in my life they can suck forever and I'll be good.You only seen the rockets be pretenders or mediocre trash your whole life.Pretenders presently,pretenders with tmac and yao,pretenders when mike was dominating.At least harden puts up great stats -
You can have the last word your feelins derailed the thread.
Wade is better than tmac in his prime imo I made my points the rest of this is you being sensitive and going off topic.Nothin you will say is gonna change my opinion we can leave it at that -
Prime Tracy McGradyThis is a hard comparison because T-Mac's career had a bunch of injuries
-
Prime Dwayne WadeThis is a hard comparison because T-Mac's career had a bunch of injuries
Not comparing careers, we're comparing their prime years. -
Prime Dwayne WadeTmac in his prime played with a hall of famer and couldnt get out the first round
-
Prime Dwayne WadeTmac in his prime played with a hall of famer and couldnt get out the first round
Smh -
-
Injuries ruined T Mac but if I could choose I'd take young pre injury T Mac over Wade.
-
Tmac in his prime played with a hall of famer and couldnt get out the first round
? cosigned like this wasn't disingenuous -
Prime Dwayne Wade
FACTS B
