Top 10 first round QB's of the past 10 years
Options
bow to royalty
Members Posts: 3,985 ✭✭✭✭✭
USA today put together this list. What do you think?
10. Teddy Bridgewater
9. Marcus Mariota
8. Jameis Winston
7. Ryan Tannehill
6. Sam Bradford
5. Joe Flacco
4. Matthew Stafford
3. Matt Ryan
2. Cam Newton
1. Andrew Luck
10. Teddy Bridgewater
9. Marcus Mariota
8. Jameis Winston
7. Ryan Tannehill
6. Sam Bradford
5. Joe Flacco
4. Matthew Stafford
3. Matt Ryan
2. Cam Newton
1. Andrew Luck
Comments
-
Luck should be 3
-
How is Bradford ranked above anybody else on that list?
-
its....JOHN B wrote: »Luck should be 3
And Ryan 1? I think Cam is too high. -
I'll give Cam a chance to rebound after that lackluster season, but right now Ryan and Cam are a toss up, just two years ago it wouldn't have been close, thisvwill be a telling year as to who's better between those two
-
its....JOHN B wrote: »I'll give Cam a chance to rebound after that lackluster season, but right now Ryan and Cam are a toss up, just two years ago it wouldn't have been close, thisvwill be a telling year as to who's better between those two
I'm giving it to Ryan easy. Cam has a career completion percentage below 60, and has only thrown for over 4,000 yards once in his career (his rookie year).
And last year wasn't a lackluster year for Cam IMO. It was a Cam year for Cam, but his one season made people forget who he was. -
Trash
-
That order is horrible
-
Andrew ? Luck?!?!?! You got to be ? me bro.
I won't even mention Cam and his 2 good seasons his entire career. There's a racial bias here for his mediocracy.
But Luck?!?!?! FOH!
Only person, on that list, that should be above Matt is wacko Flacco because of his ring.
That's it, all bs aside
-
Mariota better then all them ?
-
Ryan
Flacco
Luck
Cam -
Shizlansky wrote: »Ryan
Flacco
Luck
Cam
I'd say Luck is better than Flacco. Flacco got hot, had a great postseason, and won a SB...props for that. But he's an average QB. I'd rather have Luck as my QB, easy. -
bow to royalty wrote: »its....JOHN B wrote: »I'll give Cam a chance to rebound after that lackluster season, but right now Ryan and Cam are a toss up, just two years ago it wouldn't have been close, thisvwill be a telling year as to who's better between those two
I'm giving it to Ryan easy. Cam has a career completion percentage below 60, and has only thrown for over 4,000 yards once in his career (his rookie year).
And last year wasn't a lackluster year for Cam IMO. It was a Cam year for Cam, but his one season made people forget who he was.
Can tell you've never really watched Cam like that. This was not a typical Cam year. Cam had a streak of games last year where he was under 50% passing completion, and he had never done that before. Last year he clearly was not himself. Could all the hits finally be catching up to him? Have teams finally figured him out? Who knows...and as a panther fan, I hope not...but last year was not a typical Cam year. I've seen every game Cam has played. -
AggieLean. wrote: »bow to royalty wrote: »its....JOHN B wrote: »I'll give Cam a chance to rebound after that lackluster season, but right now Ryan and Cam are a toss up, just two years ago it wouldn't have been close, thisvwill be a telling year as to who's better between those two
I'm giving it to Ryan easy. Cam has a career completion percentage below 60, and has only thrown for over 4,000 yards once in his career (his rookie year).
And last year wasn't a lackluster year for Cam IMO. It was a Cam year for Cam, but his one season made people forget who he was.
Can tell you've never really watched Cam like that. This was not a typical Cam year. Cam had a streak of games last year where he was under 50% passing completion, and he had never done that before. Last year he clearly was not himself. Could all the hits finally be catching up to him? Have teams finally figured him out? Who knows...and as a panther fan, I hope not...but last year was not a typical Cam year. I've seen every game Cam has played.
His completion percentage dropped from bad to terrible. Ya, it's worse than usual, but I'm not sweating degrees of ? . He wasn't accurate last year...He's had an inaccurate career. -
Luck overrated AF.
I'm starting to hate that cac like I did Peyton in the early 2000's, when the media was all on his nuts and he hadn't done jack ? . -
I don't understand the love luck gets
-
I don't understand the love luck gets
Me either
He's not trash but um.....55 interceptions in 55 games is not top 5 in any category for anything but turnovers. -
numbaz...80's baby wrote: »Andrew ? Luck?!?!?! You got to be ? me bro.
I won't even mention Cam and his 2 good seasons his entire career. There's a racial bias here for his mediocracy.
But Luck?!?!?! FOH!
Only person, on that list, that should be above Matt is wacko Flacco because of his ring.
That's it, all bs aside
? you tripping I know you a falcon fan but really compare luck first 3 seasons to the other qb's on the list and see where they stand -
I would put flacco ahead of stafford because I don't see what's so great about him he's good but not great
-
vageneral08 wrote: »numbaz...80's baby wrote: »Andrew ? Luck?!?!?! You got to be ? me bro.
I won't even mention Cam and his 2 good seasons his entire career. There's a racial bias here for his mediocracy.
But Luck?!?!?! FOH!
Only person, on that list, that should be above Matt is wacko Flacco because of his ring.
That's it, all bs aside
? you tripping I know you a falcon fan but really compare luck first 3 seasons to the other qb's on the list and see where they stand
His 55 picks in 55 games voids his 1st 3 seasons. That list isnt too impressive but none of them do that. -
Ryan has not had an impressive career, just a very good season, if he shows me consistency this year I'll say it's him, I think Cam rebounds
-
How the hell Luck above Cam? Where is his super bowl appearence ? Where is his MVP? gtfoh
-
its....JOHN B wrote: »Ryan has not had an impressive career, just a very good season, if he shows me consistency this year I'll say it's him, I think Cam rebounds
Lol Cam has 2 seasons with an above 500 record in 6 years. On the other hand, Matt has 2 seasons below 500 in 9 years. This one very good season, you brought up, he's the QB of the 8th best offense in the history of the NFL.
What you mean they're neck and neck? Cam is going to rebound to another 7-9 record like he has every year. -
Only one got a ring which is the whole point in looking for that franchise QB. Only 3 made it all the way. Only one (Matt Ryan) who doesn't have one can get one. Luck is garbage like I said before. I'm glad thins worked out the way they did. Would take any other QB on the list except Ryan based off of last season at the moment.
-
its....JOHN B wrote: »Ryan has not had an impressive career, just a very good season, if he shows me consistency this year I'll say it's him, I think Cam rebounds
Rebounds to what? He's usually passing for about 3,500 yards and completing 58-59% of his passes. He's overrated as a QB. -
numbaz...80's baby wrote: »vageneral08 wrote: »numbaz...80's baby wrote: »Andrew ? Luck?!?!?! You got to be ? me bro.
I won't even mention Cam and his 2 good seasons his entire career. There's a racial bias here for his mediocracy.
But Luck?!?!?! FOH!
Only person, on that list, that should be above Matt is wacko Flacco because of his ring.
That's it, all bs aside
? you tripping I know you a falcon fan but really compare luck first 3 seasons to the other qb's on the list and see where they stand
His 55 picks in 55 games voids his 1st 3 seasons. That list isnt too impressive but none of them do that.
If you really think all 55 ints was his fault you tripping....he went deeper in the playoffs in first 3 seasons plus he does more than those other qb's with no running game
