Remember when people were saying Eli is even comparable to Peyton? Where are they now?
Options
Comments
-
Peyton is better...Eli turns up in the Playoff's, there isn't a huge difference...there really isn't you can be tight about it, but They are both hall of fame legendary quarterbacks...Eli is the best quarterback in New York (jets of giants) football history...He is a top 50 quarterback all time and a top 5 guy in the L right now...Peyton Tom Brees Rodgers Eli
-
Are we really turning this into the 103rd Peyton vs Brady argument ?
I always love those
Who brought Brady up you or me? Ok Thk u. -
what?? how is that relevant when that year without cameras they went through 18 str8 teams (one being peyton's team)? Lost in the superbowl by 3 points off of a miracle play by ELI and Tyree? also beat the giants by the same margin a few weeks back? Went to two superbowls after the camera incident and lost by 3 points, the same margin in which they won all their superbowls by, and the camera's have been proven to not have anything to do with their superbowl wins by the NFL and various coaches, and analysts....that's a grasping at straws argument..
and brady has 2 reg season mvps..i would say that's two times he out performed Peyton and also has never thrown a pick to cost his team a victory in a superbowl..that one is big because on the biggest stage.. your all world QB should never cost your team a superbowl...
in all of Eli's blunders in the reg season, he never ? up when the money was on the line, either has brady (never cost his team a superbowl in 5 tries..5!...that right there is the end all be all....it donn't mean ish what u did in the reg season...what u do when the stakes are higher...
You're wrong and an idiot Eli does ? up in the playoffs especially in the super bowls he just doesn't pay for his mistakes. Just because you make a mistake doesn't mean something bad will happen. That David Tyree catch was a bad play by Eli every qb is told never to do what Eli. For one thing there was another player open on that 3rd and 5 and another thing is it was the last drive and he still had a 4 th down. Eli tossed the ball across his body into the middle of the field where a defender was right on Tyree 9/10 thats a int when Peyton manning did it on his final play last yr against the ravens it was a pick.
-
BlackxChild wrote: »You're wrong and an idiot Eli does ? up in the playoffs especially in the super bowls he just doesn't pay for his mistakes. Just because you make a mistake doesn't mean something bad will happen. That David Tyree catch was a bad play by Eli every qb is told never to do what Eli. For one thing there was another player open on that 3rd and 5 and another thing is it was the last drive and he still had a 4 th down. Eli tossed the ball across his body into the middle of the field where a defender was right on Tyree 9/10 thats a int when Peyton manning did it on his final play last yr against the ravens it was a pick.
first off, i said he has never cost his teams a superbowl, when they needed him to step up has he? nope!!
2nd ? boy, when a QB is trying to avoid a rush and with in secs of being brought down and a superbowl victory all proper techniques get thrown out the window in that situation it's to make a play however you can....EVERYONE IN FOOTBALL KNOWS THAT.
and again when you are being rushed you have no more time to scan the field, you have linemen all over you..smh
3rd nobody ever said there isnt a bit of luck in football at times, but that doesnt take away from costly mistake when it happens, when you ? up, you ? up; Point blank....Manning was not being rushed, he had plenty of time to scan the field for this cerebral QB and he threw a pick six....nobody said it took away from his overall evaluation as a QB...but we aint gonna act like "there's isnt an elphant in the room"
when u evaluate a player u pick apart everything about them... -
Elzo did. Now go cry somewhere else -
Elzo did. Now go cry somewhere else
this is what you came back with!!??
garbage ass poster. -
U mad or nah ?
-
Eli numbers is the same as Peyton in the playoffs.
But their team defensive numbers is different.
So Flacco > Peyton by Yall logic -
Flacco had a passer rating of 1 and they won the game.
Defend that ? -
Team game
That's what I'm saying and that went over your head -
? boy your dumb if you break a tackle and no ones open throw it out of bounds instead of risking a int...BlackxChild wrote: »You're wrong and an idiot Eli does ? up in the playoffs especially in the super bowls he just doesn't pay for his mistakes. Just because you make a mistake doesn't mean something bad will happen. That David Tyree catch was a bad play by Eli every qb is told never to do what Eli. For one thing there was another player open on that 3rd and 5 and another thing is it was the last drive and he still had a 4 th down. Eli tossed the ball across his body into the middle of the field where a defender was right on Tyree 9/10 thats a int when Peyton manning did it on his final play last yr against the ravens it was a pick.
first off, i said he has never cost his teams a superbowl, when they needed him to step up has he? nope!!
2nd ? boy, when a QB is trying to avoid a rush and with in secs of being brought down and a superbowl victory all proper techniques get thrown out the window in that situation it's to make a play however you can....EVERYONE IN FOOTBALL KNOWS THAT.
and again when you are being rushed you have no more time to scan the field, you have linemen all over you..smh
3rd nobody ever said there isnt a bit of luck in football at times, but that doesnt take away from costly mistake when it happens, when you ? up, you ? up; Point blank....Manning was not being rushed, he had plenty of time to scan the field for this cerebral QB and he threw a pick six....nobody said it took away from his overall evaluation as a QB...but we aint gonna act like "there's isnt an elphant in the room"
when u evaluate a player u pick apart everything about them...
-
ParallelRhymes wrote: »So you lose the Eli argument and now we move onto Flacco...at least an argument can be posed there.
Despite the fact Flacco just had one of the greatest Super Bowl runs ever just last season.....
Flacco really didn't if you actually watched what happened he made plenty of bad decisions. I also like how ppl say flacco should've beat the pats the season before despite him playing like complete trash the week before against the texans. Winning is a team thing winning is not a qb stat it's a team stat. -
So ? are saying... ALL ELSE BEING EQUAL (same team, coach, opposition, weapons etc...)... you'd rather have Eli than Peyton as your starting QB in a Superbowl?
-
BlackxChild wrote: »? boy your dumb if you break a tackle and no ones open throw it out of bounds instead of risking a int...
"but but but Eli should not of threw it cross his body, he had a man open (and no he didnt by the way), his mechanics were all wrong...."
dont post in here again!
and it's 3 and 5 in a superbowl ? ...u dont just throw it away, u make a play!! -
ParallelRhymes wrote: »
Whatever you are trying to say doesn't answer the question.
