Who Has More Classic Albums Eminem or Jay Z???
Options
GetoBoy
Members Posts: 3,879 ✭✭✭✭✭
in The Reason
Comments
-
They both only have one classic to me.
-
Jay, and it's not even close.
-
Jayz easy cause Eminem has none
-
Eminem easily
The Slim Shady LP, The Marshall Mathers LP, The Eminem Show, The Marshall Mathers LP 2
Jay Z doesn't have a classic album to me -
imo they both got three
The Slim Shady LP
MMLP
TES
Reasonable doubt
TBP
the black album
jay has more above average albums (vol 1, vol 2, American Gangster, dynasty compared to relapse)
em has more wack albums (recovery, encore compared to kingdom come)
the top 2 in my top 5 -
SuperSoaker wrote: »imo they both got three
The Slim Shady LP
MMLP
TES
Reasonable doubt
TBP
the black album
jay has more above average albums (vol 1, vol 2, American Gangster, dynasty compared to relapse)
em has more wack albums (recovery, encore compared to kingdom come)
the top 2 in my top 5
Don't forget Blueprint 2.
I'd add MMLP2 Deluxe to Em's classic list.
-
SuperSoaker wrote: »imo they both got three
The Slim Shady LP
MMLP
TES
Reasonable doubt
TBP
the black album
jay has more above average albums (vol 1, vol 2, American Gangster, dynasty compared to relapse)
em has more wack albums (recovery, encore compared to kingdom come)
Cosign everything above. -
Eminem -
Classic albums - The Slim Shady LP, The Marshall Mathers LP, The Eminem Show, The Marshall Mathers LP 2
Good albums - Recovery
Below average albums - Encore
Wack albums - Relapse
Jay Z -
Classic albums - 0
Good albums - Reasonable Doubt, The Blueprint
Average albums - The Black Album, American Gangster
Below average albums - Volume 1
Wack albums - Kingdome Come, Volume 1, Volume 2, Blueprint 2, The Dynasty, Magna Carter Holy Grail,
Blueprint 3 -
Imo I'll give Jay 3 for Reasonable Doubt, The Blueprint, and The Black Album with two pretty close ones in Vol. 2 and American Gangster.....Eminem I'd give one with SSLP with The Eminem Show being close but even if I gave him two he ain't got more then Jay unless you just a em stan then wanna probably give em 4 and jay none
-
mmlp2 was very average. and that is me being generous
-
Jay Z has more.
Eminem - SSLP and MMLP
Jay Z - Reasonable Doubt, Blue Print, Black Album (some may argue that American Gangster and atleast one of the Vol.s were classic as well) -
Eminem's best album - The Eminem Show
Jay Z's best album - Reasonable Doubt
Eminem's worst album - Relapse
Jay Z's worst album - Kingdome Come -
BLueprint 3 is not whack. It's not classic but there's a lot of good songs on there
-
Eminem
-
Honestly, I can't listen to an Eminem album. His voice gets annoying after a while. And his beats don't have any boom bap. His beats are bland.
Jay Z wins this by a landslide. -
Imo I'll give Jay 3 for Reasonable Doubt, The Blueprint, and The Black Album with two pretty close ones in Vol. 2 and American Gangster.....Eminem I'd give one with SSLP with The Eminem Show being close but even if I gave him two he ain't got more then Jay unless you just a em stan then wanna probably give em 4 and jay none
MMLP isn't classic to you? -
Jaw Breaker wrote: »Eminem
-
BLueprint 3 is not whack. It's not classic but there's a lot of good songs on there
1 of the worst albums i heard -
Eminem has no classic albums.
-
-
Some good ass weed being smoke in here
-
? dont even have the same definition for classic. all people do most of the time is list their favorite albums in this classic debate anyway. thats why i try not to get into it
jay has the better catalog than em anyway. comparing jays best albums imo to ems (blueprint, AG vs. the eminem show, MMLP) jay wins
compare their good albums, jay wins
compare their mediocre albums, jay wins
compare their worst albums, jay wins
both are two of my favorite but i rock with jays music more -
Plain and simply, Jay makes better music than Eminem and its not even close.
-
im pretty sure we are going for certified majority rules classic and not personal...if thats the case then jay has rd and bp and em has 1 the marshall mathers lp. if u debating then jay still wins as people will argue about more of his albums being classic than em's.
a good album doesnt make it classic...your fav album doesnt = classic. -
Thread starter do u have twitter?
On twitter make a tweet asking the same question telling people to R.T. if they think Eminem does or R.T. if they think Jay Z does
I gurantee u Eminem will win by a landslide
This discussion has been closed.