Remember when people were saying Eli is even comparable to Peyton? Where are they now?
Options
bow to royalty
Members Posts: 3,985 ✭✭✭✭✭
Remember after Eli got his 2nd ring people started saying this dumb ? ? I just thought of it again during this Denver vs Oakland game. Peyton's a damn beast...
Comments
-
I been second guessing this game Sunday
0-3 team is desperate
We gotta take care of business
No reason the giants should be this bad -
ParallelRhymes wrote: »I usually heard people say that
Peyton >>>>> Eli....regular season
Eli >>>>> Peyton...playoffs
I still can't really disagree with that tbh.
It may sound funny, but I kinda disagree with that. I'll let other people speak on it some more before I explain why though. -
I been second guessing this game Sunday
0-3 team is desperate
We gotta take care of business
No reason the giants should be this bad
Glad to see your team doing well. As someone who understands seeing their team be ? week after week, it's good to see someone livin the good life. -
I been second guessing this game Sunday
0-3 team is desperate
We gotta take care of business
No reason the giants should be this bad
We coming for yall ?
Hopefully.. -
Eli Manning rode his defensive lines back to two super bowls and only a stan would say otherwise.
-
That being said....i think kc takes care of business
If this game was in ny i would have my doubts -
How many times have Eli missed the playoffs?
-
Its laughable to say Peyton has had more success once in the playoffs than Eli
It's also laughable to think at this moment ANYONE would say Eli > Peyton -
ParallelRhymes wrote: »Eli's been to the postseason 5 times and won the Super Bowl 2 times.
Peyton has been 12 times and won the SB once.
They both been twice so that's washed..
Only 5 appearances is not a good thing
Missing the playoffs is just like taking a L your first game in the post season. -
bow to royalty wrote: »ParallelRhymes wrote: »I usually heard people say that
Peyton >>>>> Eli....regular season
Eli >>>>> Peyton...playoffs
I still can't really disagree with that tbh.
It may sound funny, but I kinda disagree with that. I'll let other people speak on it some more before I explain why though.
Let's hear this explanation. -
Shizlansky wrote: »ParallelRhymes wrote: »Eli's been to the postseason 5 times and won the Super Bowl 2 times.
Peyton has been 12 times and won the SB once.
They both been twice so that's washed..
Only 5 appearances is not a good thing
Missing the playoffs is just like taking a L your first game in the post season.
Going to the Super Bowl and winning it are completely different, so no, it's not a wash. -
Shizlansky wrote: »ParallelRhymes wrote: »Eli's been to the postseason 5 times and won the Super Bowl 2 times.
Peyton has been 12 times and won the SB once.
They both been twice so that's washed..
Only 5 appearances is not a good thing
Missing the playoffs is just like taking a L your first game in the post season.
Eli never had a losing season as a starter though going 9-7 several times or 10-6 and missing the playoffs those years, is that a losing team?
-
That defense is why they beat Kansas, Baltimore, and NE. Grossman lost that SB for the Bears.He still wont have a Tom Brady 18-1 season.Of course he better than Eli and he would be Eli if he was the Giants QB.ParallelRhymes wrote: »bow to royalty wrote: »ParallelRhymes wrote: »I usually heard people say that
Peyton >>>>> Eli....regular season
Eli >>>>> Peyton...playoffs
I still can't really disagree with that tbh.
It may sound funny, but I kinda disagree with that. I'll let other people speak on it some more before I explain why though.
(P) Manning hasn't proven anything in the playoffs really...in 2006 when they won the Super Bowl he had 3 TDs and 7 INTs through the Playoffs.
I'll wait though, you said you are prepared.
-
That front 4 kept Brady in check
Ryan, Rodgers.
Eli barely put up points
The defense win them rings
As we can see right now their defense is ? and look how he's playing..
-
I'll take both of Eli's SB runs over Peyton Manning's SB run, as I would hope every objective person would, numbers don't lie.
-
Shizlansky wrote: »That front 4 kept Brady in check
Ryan, Rodgers.
Eli barely put up points
The defense win them rings
As we can see right now their defense is ? and look how he's playing..
Well here goes the last Super Bowl run with stats against all three QBs you just named.
1/8/2011 vs ATL
23-32 277yds 3Tds 0Ints
1/15/2011 @ GB
21/33 330yds 3Tds 1Int
1/22/2011 @ SF
32/58 316yds 2Tds 0Ints
2/5/2011 vs NE
30/40 296yds 1Td 0Ints
Yes the Defense was a big part of them winning the both Super Bowls but to say that Eli didn't do anything means that you already had in your mind that he didn't do much. -
bow to royalty wrote: »ParallelRhymes wrote: »I usually heard people say that
Peyton >>>>> Eli....regular season
Eli >>>>> Peyton...playoffs
I still can't really disagree with that tbh.
It may sound funny, but I kinda disagree with that. I'll let other people speak on it some more before I explain why though.
Let's hear this explanation.ParallelRhymes wrote: »bow to royalty wrote: »ParallelRhymes wrote: »I usually heard people say that
Peyton >>>>> Eli....regular season
Eli >>>>> Peyton...playoffs
I still can't really disagree with that tbh.
It may sound funny, but I kinda disagree with that. I'll let other people speak on it some more before I explain why though.
(P) Manning hasn't proven anything in the playoffs really...in 2006 when they won the Super Bowl he had 3 TDs and 7 INTs through the Playoffs.
I'll wait though, you said you are prepared.
Shizlansky got part of it. Eli's only been to the playoffs 5 times. Looks like he won't be going this year, so he's on his way to 5 trips to the playoffs in 10 years. So you're putting Peyton's 1 and done as a con for Peyton, but not penalizing Eli for missing the playoffs.
Second thing. I want to go ahead and give Eli credit for winning 2 SBs. That's not easy and he did it...so props to him. But those ARE the only 2 years he's won a playoff game in what's coming up on 10 years. So I'm not too quick to call him this great post-season player.
I can see the argument for Eli being the better post-season QB, but I don't think the gap is that big. And it's not nearly as big as the regular season gap between them -
Team game.
-
Overall Peyt Manning is better due to consistency. All Peyt Manning has to do really at least to his dickriders is win one more superbowl to be considered the greatest QB of all time. Personally I think Peyt needs at least 3 like Brady but it is what it is. Elis playoff Performance minus those two superbowl years gotta be lacking somewhat to if he even makes the playoffs.
If we took a poll right now 98% of NFL fans would pick Peyt over Eli. -
ParallelRhymes wrote: »Bringing up the fact he's only been to 5 playoffs just proves he sucks in the regular season and winning 2 out of 5 trips says a lot more than 1 out of 12 last time I checked.
Y'all are doing a better job arguing for my point than I am.
Thats still over half his playoff appearances being one and done. with that said, I'm still not looking at him as some post season monster. So like I said, i seee the argument for Eli I just don't think its a huge gap -
Separating playoffs from regular season is laughable
I'm not separating ? , to give one QB the advantage
Peyton is far better than him and any other QB of this generation
-
I dont know where they are but i'm pretty sure that it was true at the time that they made the statement.
-
cParallelRhymes wrote: »bow to royalty wrote: »ParallelRhymes wrote: »Bringing up the fact he's only been to 5 playoffs just proves he sucks in the regular season and winning 2 out of 5 trips says a lot more than 1 out of 12 last time I checked.
Y'all are doing a better job arguing for my point than I am.
Thats still over half his playoff appearances being one and done. with that said, I'm still not looking at him as some post season monster. So like I said, i seee the argument for Eli I just don't think its a huge gap
I'm not saying that it is a tremendous gap but I think it's obvious Eli has done more in the postseason.
Also, Eli has been 1 and done 3 times in 5 appearances (60 percent). Peyton has been 1 and done 8 times in 12 appearances (75 percent).
Thanks again broham
I agree with you that eli has had a better playoff resume. I'm just saying its not as big of a gap as some say. -
Separating playoffs from regular season is laughable
I'm not separating ? , to give one QB the advantage
Peyton is far better than him and any other QB of this generation
Very very true. Sanchez has 2 AFC championship appearances, 9 TD 2 Int, 4 wins 2 losses, wins against peyton and brady, and a rating of 94.3 in the playoffs, and nobody is jumping up to separate regular season, from post season for him. -
They changed the rules for Peyton he only got 1 ring remember leave the Colts wrs alone
