TOP 5 QBs OF ALL TIME IN YOUR OPINION
Options
jjswipe
Members Posts: 1,039 ✭✭
List your top 5 qbs of all time. Lets keep it civil and respect each other's opinion. Unless if a ? talking out his ass and say a ? like ryan leaf or akili smith. Scratch that, we're all men, we can all take some criticism, so hey what you feel. Here's my top 5, no particular order.
I'm only naming cats that i have seen play. I can't speak on the bradshaws, and fouts' cuz i've never seen them play live
1. Joe montana- joe cool. Nuff said.
2. Steve young- may not have been a star for a long period of time, but when he got his shot, he took flight. That super bowl against the chargers is one of the best postseason showing by any qb
3. Peyton manning- could go down as the greatest ever. He just needs those super bowl rings like montana, and brady so there won't be any 'buts' when people say how good he is.
4. John elway- the comeback kid. Those last 2 super bowls cememnted his legacy. He was a sure hof.
5. Three way tie between dan marino, brett favre, and tom brady.
Marino has the numbers but of course, no ring.
Favre damn near owns every qb record and a ring. But he also has the most picks in league history. Jordan had the pull up jumper to end his career(the 1st time), favre has a pick against the giants(the 1st retirement) and a pick against the saints(this retirement???) that cost his squads a super bowl appearance.
Brady is a beast, but he's a patriot and fucc the patriots. That was a blatant fumble. I digress, but the boy's resume is impressive
I'm only naming cats that i have seen play. I can't speak on the bradshaws, and fouts' cuz i've never seen them play live
1. Joe montana- joe cool. Nuff said.
2. Steve young- may not have been a star for a long period of time, but when he got his shot, he took flight. That super bowl against the chargers is one of the best postseason showing by any qb
3. Peyton manning- could go down as the greatest ever. He just needs those super bowl rings like montana, and brady so there won't be any 'buts' when people say how good he is.
4. John elway- the comeback kid. Those last 2 super bowls cememnted his legacy. He was a sure hof.
5. Three way tie between dan marino, brett favre, and tom brady.
Marino has the numbers but of course, no ring.
Favre damn near owns every qb record and a ring. But he also has the most picks in league history. Jordan had the pull up jumper to end his career(the 1st time), favre has a pick against the giants(the 1st retirement) and a pick against the saints(this retirement???) that cost his squads a super bowl appearance.
Brady is a beast, but he's a patriot and fucc the patriots. That was a blatant fumble. I digress, but the boy's resume is impressive
Comments
-
Joe Montana
John Elway/Johnny Unitas
Tom Brady
Peyton Manning
Brett Favre -
if peyton wins this sunday...
1) peyton
2) montana
3) brady
4) elway
5) young -
1. Montana
2. Brady
3. Elway
4. Favre
5. Marino -
1.Elway(Is the most talented one out the five in my opinion and won 2 SB and played in a total of 5 and was clutch)
2.Peyton(Smartest QB ever..Just slices up Defenses Constantly ,1SB)
3.Montana(I love Montana but he did play on loaded teams and had the best reciever of all-time and arguably the best fball player ever)
4.Marino (Wasn't his fault he didn't win a ring never had the talent of the other four around him)
5.Brady(3 super bowls and proved with top tier weapons he could put up the stats too) -
If Saints win Sunday
1.Montana
2.Brady
3.Elway
4.Young
5.Manning
If Colts Win
1.Montana
2.Manning
3.Brady
4.Elway
5.Young -
1. Manning
2. Marino
3.Montana
4.Brady
5.Favre -
1.warren moon
2.brett fvre
3.joe montana
4.john elway
5.peyton manning -
sneekay1518 wrote: »1.warren moon
2.brett fvre
3.joe montana
4.john elway
5.peyton manning
lol @ warren moon being the GOAT...
1. Manning
2. Montana
3. Elway
4. Marino
5. Brady -
Brady
Young
Montana
Marino
Warner -
Peyton
Unitas
Montana
Brady
Favre -
Aikmam gets no love, where dey do dat at.
-
1. Joe Montana
2. Fran Tarkenton (However you spell it) He just couldnt win the big game due to other players.
3. Brady
4. Manning
5.Marino -
Manning
Montana
Favre
Young
Brady -
that ? had kurt warner but no peyton manning... wow
-
Yeah, i tripped off him having Warner up there as well. The thing about Warner was when he was good, he was great, but then he also had trashy seasons in between. Too much up and down for me. And i forgot about Aikman. He didnt really have astounding regular season numbers, but that boy turnt it all the way up come playoff time
-
1.Elway
2.Manning
3.Montana
4.Brady
5.Marino
On the outside looking in: Unitas& Favre -
yogirlsxman wrote: »1. Joe Montana
2. Fran Tarkenton (However you spell it) He just couldnt win the big game due to other players.
3. Brady
4. Manning
5.Marino
what do you mean by that? -
Peyton Manning is that dude right now. his preciseness and knowledge of the game is unmatched right now but he needs a couple more rings to get on the list. 1 montana. 2 elway. 3 brady 4 dan fouts(the only 1 without a ring). 5 steve young.
-
I had to rethink some things. How can terry bradshaw not even be mentioned in this thread. fran tarkington. no . bradshaws got 4 rings. I have to replace dan fouts and put terry on this list.
-
themadlionsfan wrote: »what do you mean by that?
He was a Vick before Vick. He would make a lot of plays with his feet rarely in the pocket. He also would run down field and pitch the ball to random players. It worked with the Vikings. They just never had the talent. He got traded to a better team the Giants. The players just were used to his style. Its kinda like making Tebow play for the Pats. -
No order really
Manning
Marino
Montana
Elway
Favre -
1. Joe Montana
2. Dan Marino
3. Tom Brady
4. Doug Williams
5. Michael Vick -
P Manning
D Marino
B Favre
J Montana
J Elway -
makaveli4ever wrote: »No order really
Manning
Marino
Montana
Elway
Favre
co-sign..... -
Manning
Montana
Marino
Young
Brady
