The Official Rookie Of The Year Award Thread
Options
Stew
Members, Moderators, Writer Posts: 52,234 Regulator
Arguably the toughest ROTY vote ever. Who u got?
The Official Rookie Of The Year Award Thread 38 votes
Comments
-
Robert Griffin IIIOf course my vote is Griff..but if Russ won it I wouldn't trip. Those two are 1a and 1b.
-
where are the other nominees?
-
Robert Griffin IIISeawawks was average/good without wilson. they just needed a qb. Andrew Luck been saved by his Defense plenty of times and throws a lot of picks.
-
Robert Griffin IIIRGIII All Day Long. But I ain't mad at Luck or Wilson. They're making it happen too.
-
MikeydaGawd wrote: »Seawawks was average/good without wilson. they just needed a qb. Andrew Luck been saved by his Defense plenty of times and throws a lot of picks.
you do realize that the seattle has a top 5 defense and the colts/redskins are somewhere in the bottom 10 right? -
Robert Griffin IIIwhere are the other nominees?
lol they dont matter.
I could make a strong case for Wilson too no one expected anything out of him.. and thought that he was a fluke in the preseason
-
Robert Griffin IIIMikeydaGawd wrote: »Seawawks was average/good without wilson. they just needed a qb. Andrew Luck throws a lot of picks.
you do realize that the seattle has a top 5 defense and the colts/redskins are somewhere in the bottom 10 right?
that is why i said seahawks was a good/average team without Wilson. but i coulda sworn colts d were better than i thought guess not. -
playmaker88 wrote: »
luke kuechly is up for the defensive award. so if its a thread for the rookie of the year, then yeah it matters to me damnit -
MikeydaGawd wrote: »MikeydaGawd wrote: »Seawawks was average/good without wilson. they just needed a qb. Andrew Luck throws a lot of picks.
you do realize that the seattle has a top 5 defense and the colts/redskins are somewhere in the bottom 10 right?
that is why i said seahawks was a good/average team without Wilson. but i coulda sworn colts d were better than i thought guess not.
and the colts were a ? terrible team without luck now they are a playoff team. -
Andrew LuckMikeydaGawd wrote: »Seawawks was average/good without wilson. they just needed a qb. Andrew Luck been saved by his Defense plenty of times and throws a lot of picks.
? you dont watch none of the games....? outta here -
Andrew LuckJust based on him have 7 comeback wins this season, broke the rookie passing record, and has his team in the playoffs....? sounds good to me
-
RGIII, then Wilson.
-
this is a tough one, i think we will have co rookies of the year.
Russ and RG3 -
Wilson and RG3 will split the black vote
-
Robert Griffin IIIvageneral08 wrote: »Just based on him have 7 comeback wins this season, broke the rookie passing record, and has his team in the playoffs....? sounds good to me
Him throwing picks early in games helping the team get into early holes are partially attributed to him having comeback opportunities..
It's like praising an arsonist for putting out his own fires. -
Luck is probably going to take it. Just broke rookie passing yards record and took Indy from not mentioned at all to the playoffs. This could get a bit more close if Redskins get into the playoffs. I think RW finishes 3rd no matter what though.
-
Based on the actual "value" of the player to the team, and I'd have to say Luck. But I feel like Russell Wilson is *currently* better than the other two.
However, after a careful, forensic audit.....
I filled this bucket up with all the ? I give.
-
Andrew Luckvageneral08 wrote: »Just based on him have 7 comeback wins this season, broke the rookie passing record, and has his team in the playoffs....? sounds good to me
Him throwing picks early in games helping the team get into early holes are partially attributed to him having comeback opportunities..
It's like praising an arsonist for putting out his own fires.
smh you still thinking like an ass stewie......? we was down most of the game against green bay not because of his turnovers but because the defense couldnt make the stops when most needed.....bottom line you cant put drew stanton in and say we can win.....just remember redskins won two games without RG3 so that alone will be looked at too....wilson is good but without the good defense seahawks wouldnt be the playoffs period so whoever wins it I'm cool with it -
Robert Griffin III1. RG3 , 2. Wilson , 3. Luck
-
Robert Griffin IIILol Won two games? Griff played the majority of that last drive then Kirk came in and made two big plays. Then in OT Rich Crawford's return put us in FG range. So you were saying.
All three have a similar amount of wins. Because of that you then have to go to stats and Griff and Russ have outplayed Luck in that department. Get mad.
Four straight games under 49% completion percentage. Them Tebow numbers LMAO. -
Andrew LuckLol Won two games? Griff played the majority of that last drive then Kirk came in and made two big plays. Then in OT Rich Crawford's return put us in FG range. So you were saying.
All three have a similar amount of wins. Because of that you then have to go to stats and Griff and Russ have outplayed Luck in that department. Get mad.
Four straight games under 49% completion percentage. Them Tebow numbers LMAO.
ok he wasnt playing on the game winning drive if ya'll had lost you wouldnt be saying that ? and you ? wasnt even sure ya'll would win with RG3 so dont act cocky now because ya'll just started winning again.....luck bout to throw for 4400 yards most yards by a rookie ever so ya'll keep missing me with that stat ? .....almost any rookie qb can succeed in that basic ass offense ya'll run open up the playbook for RG3 then holla at me -
So it has begun...
Peyton vs Brady
Flacco vs Ryan.
RGIII vs Luck.
-
Robert Griffin IIIvageneral08 wrote: »Lol Won two games? Griff played the majority of that last drive then Kirk came in and made two big plays. Then in OT Rich Crawford's return put us in FG range. So you were saying.
All three have a similar amount of wins. Because of that you then have to go to stats and Griff and Russ have outplayed Luck in that department. Get mad.
Four straight games under 49% completion percentage. Them Tebow numbers LMAO.
ok he wasnt playing on the game winning drive if ya'll had lost you wouldnt be saying that ? and you ? wasnt even sure ya'll would win with RG3 so dont act cocky now because ya'll just started winning again.....luck bout to throw for 4400 yards most yards by a rookie ever so ya'll keep missing me with that stat ? .....almost any rookie qb can succeed in that basic ass offense ya'll run open up the playbook for RG3 then holla at me
Says a stat to prop up his QB, then says miss me with stats.
-
greenwood1921 wrote: »So it has begun...
Peyton vs Brady
Romo vs Vick
Flacco vs Ryan.
RGIII vs Luck.
Forgot one. -
Russell WilsonRg3 isn't going to win r.o.y and I would put money on that.
I think luck or wilson got it.