Adolf Trump: 'Why was there the Civil War? Why could that one not have been worked out?'…
Options
stringer bell
Members Posts: 26,212 ✭✭✭✭✭
http://talkingpointsmemo.com/livewire/trump-why-was-there-the-civil-war
Trump Takes Latest Stab At Historical Analysis: ‘Why Was There The Civil War?’ – Talking Points Memo
President Donald Trump on Monday questioned why the Civil War occurred: “Why could that one not have been worked out?”
In an interview with Washington Examiner reporter Salena Zito on SiriusXM show “Main Street Meets the Beltway,” Trump compared his campaign and election victory — now over for more than six months — to those of Andrew Jackson, an analogy Trump has courted since his inauguration.
“They said my campaign is most like, my campaign and win, was most like Andrew Jackson,” Trump said. “I said, ‘When was Andrew Jackson?’ It was 1828. That’s a long time ago.”
The comparison might be less apt than Trump would like. Before Jackson was elected president, he killed a man he accused of insulting his wife in a duel.
Trump appeared to praise Jackson, a slaveholder who was accused of slave trading and who owned approximately 150 people at the time of his death, as a “swashbuckler.”
“Had Andrew Jackson been a little later, you wouldn’t have had the Civil War,” Trump said. “He was a very tough person, but he had a big heart.” (Jackson engineered the deaths of thousands of Native Americans while he was in office.)
“He was really angry that he saw what was happening with regard to the Civil War, he said, ‘There’s no reason for this,'” Trump continued. “People don’t realize, you know, the Civil War, you think about it, why? People don’t ask that question, but why was there the Civil War? Why could that one not have been worked out?”
In fact, Jackson died in 1845, long before the Civil War began in 1861, when seven southern slave states seceded after President Abraham Lincoln won election on a platform opposing the expansion of slavery into the territories. A total of 11 states eventually formed the Confederate States of America.
Trump’s last unsuccessful foray into the history of slavery in the United States fell flat when he described 19th-century black abolitionist leader, social reformer and writer Frederick Douglass as “somebody who has done an amazing job and is being recognized more and more.”
Comments
-
TF!!!
-
? always sounds like that kid who didn't do the homework but tries to ? his way through questions.
Homeboy probably just learned who Andrew Jackson was last week and now is gassing him up so people will think he knows his American history.
This man will be forever an ether to all those whites who voted him in. In 50 years supporting Trump will be like supporting segregation: you won't be able to find a single white person to admit they did it. -
Don't know how he still has supporters
-
Then again he's turning pu$$y when he's confronted about the wiretapping claims...
-
Too bad Trump wasn't there to do the Art of the Deal. So much easier than repealing Obamacare, implementing his own better Trumpcare and banning immigrants, learning the Constitution, etc. etc.
-
-
Outside of bullshitting people exactly what qualities or knowledge does this sloppy ? posses that makes him good to lead a country?
Angela Merkel had to tell him eleven times he couldn't do a trade deal with Germany bc they were part of the EU...he didnt understand.
Someone had to explain to him the north and south korea situation
He doesnt even understand the checks and balances of our govt.
I can see trump being the beginning of the end of american dominance.
-
"He had a big heart"
Not according to history.
President Orange needs to sit down. -
? sad but hilarious how this guy just goes on about ? with no ? given it's like dude been wealthy damn near most his life so he prob didn't give a ? about school to learn and now that he's in office he might open a book see a paragraph of a time in history and for that day he'll make a statement comparing then and now
-
dalyricalbandit wrote: »? sad but hilarious how this guy just goes on about ? with no ? given it's like dude been wealthy damn near most his life so he prob didn't give a ? about school to learn and now that he's in office he might open a book see a paragraph of a time in history and for that day he'll make a statement comparing then and now
True.. It's ironic this orange ? had the audacity to go around questioning Barry's educational background and demanding to see his transcripts.. Smh... -
Outside of bullshitting people exactly what qualities or knowledge does this sloppy ? posses that makes him good to lead a country?
Angela Merkel had to tell him eleven times he couldn't do a trade deal with Germany bc they were part of the EU...he didnt understand.
Someone had to explain to him the north and south korea situation
He doesnt even understand the checks and balances of our govt.
I can see trump being the beginning of the end of american dominance.
American dominance is a myth.
I mean America still has the strongest military, but other countries been slowly pulling ahead of the U.S. in education, manufacturing, etc for years.
The U.S. better be glad countries like China, Mexico, and Japan for instance love that American currency.
Chances are your smartphone, clothes you're wearing, computer you're using, apps that make your life easier, car that you drive, etc is probably manufacturered in one of those places.
If those countries one day decided that they no longer wanted to do business with us we'd go back to the stoneages here. The casual American consumer is ignorant to a lot of that. The U.S. ain't as independent as one would like to think. -
“He was really angry that he saw what was happening with regard to the Civil War, he said, ‘There’s no reason for this,'” Trump continued. “People don’t realize, you know, the Civil War, you think about it, why? People don’t ask that question, but why was there the Civil War? Why could that one not have been worked out?”
Translation: "Why couldn't they work out a deal to preserve slavery and avoid the civil war?" -
Undefeatable wrote: »“He was really angry that he saw what was happening with regard to the Civil War, he said, ‘There’s no reason for this,'” Trump continued. “People don’t realize, you know, the Civil War, you think about it, why? People don’t ask that question, but why was there the Civil War? Why could that one not have been worked out?”
Translation: "Why couldn't they work out a deal to preserve slavery and avoid the civil war?"
You pretty much nailed it.
He stopped short of saying that, but I have a feeling thats exactly what he was thinking especially when you consider him throwing Andrew Jackson's name around. -
Outside of bullshitting people exactly what qualities or knowledge does this sloppy ? posses that makes him good to lead a country?
Angela Merkel had to tell him eleven times he couldn't do a trade deal with Germany bc they were part of the EU...he didnt understand.
Someone had to explain to him the north and south korea situation
He doesnt even understand the checks and balances of our govt.
I can see trump being the beginning of the end of american dominance.
"We're tired of the same old ? !" we need an outsider!" "Trump is a great businessman!" ? from stupid ass trump supporters during his campaign -
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ceaDPq48mPE
http://crooksandliars.com/2017/05/cnn-conservative-stop-making-civil-war-allConservative CNN Panelist Whines About 'Race Card Being Thrown Around' Over Civil War
Conservative CNN pundit Ben Ferguson lost his temper with Bakari Sellers for relating the issue of slavery to the Civil War, yelling, "People are getting sick and tired of the race card being thrown around."
This left Sellers stunned. Bakari never called Trump, Ferguson or conservatives racists over Trump's asinine comments, but the mention of any type of race relations is now throwing conservatives into a deep funk.
This began as a typical CNN panel debate over something moronic Trump said either in an interview or on Twitter.
This time is was during an interview with the Washington Examiner's Salena Zito where he said, "had Andrew Jackson been a little later, you wouldn't have had the Civil War."
In response to Trump claiming Andrew Jackson could have stopped the civil war, CNN's Ben Ferguson tried to unpackage what Trump actually meant, as do most Trump surrogates or apologists.
Ferguson said that the media was overreacting to what Trump had said, and then backed up Trump's claims by alleging Jackson understood how brutal war is and that Trump admires the man for hating elites.
"He liked giving power back to the people. He sees a lot of similarities between his presidential campaign and also the other campaign as well, so i think this has been taken out of context in a major way," Ferguson said.
Bakari Sellers would have none of it and replied, '[Trump] says something outlandish or in this case, very ignorant and friends of mine like Ben Ferguson have to clean it up and spin it the best possible way."
CNN host asked, "Why do you say ignorance?"
Sellers explained that it was "historically ignorant," because Jackson committed genocide on the American Indians and was a slave owner himself, we know why the war was fought. "For Donald Trump to ask himself why was the Civil War fought is historically ignorant you're entitled to your own opinion. You're not entitled to your own facts. That's my problem with this revisionist whitewash of history."
This infuriated Ferguson, who said, "People are getting sick and tired of the race card being thrown around. When you have a president that's looking back historically at an individual that understood exactly how brutal war was."
Then the CNN conservative went off the deep end trying to rewrite history and say there were many other factors that created the Civil war other than slavery.
Bakari had enough. (rough transcript ahead)
Sellers: Why was the civil war fought?
Ferguson: I think you know this and I know this A large part of it was slavery. There was also large parts -"
Sellers: There are no two ways to look at his.
Ferguson: You said facts matter!"
Sellers: You cannot say this is an economic matter because do you know what the economics of that time were? Slavery.
No one is playing the race card when we're talking about the civil war. Point, blank, period. The fact is if Donald Trump wants to postulate why was the Civil war fought, the answer is slavery. Move forward.
Ferguson: Bakari, you're being ignorant to history if you think the civil war, go back and look at any history book was solely about slavery. It was not solely about slavery and if you actually look at history instead of just throwing race out there on every single thing when it comes to Civil war, you'd have a better understanding."
Sellers: I actually was a history major, Ben.
Ferguson: You weren't paying good attention.
Sellers: This is absurd.
Ferguson: It's not absurd. It's absurd to imply that the Civil war exclusively about slavery. The entire thing was not slavery.
OK, children. From now on, the Civil war wasn't mostly about slavery, got it?
Watch out Jeffrey Lord, somebody wants to steal your mantle of being the biggest ? on CNN and television over the history of race relations in America.
Editor's note: The Civil War was entirely about slavery. This is a whitewash conservatives and bigots put on it to deny their racism and pretend they are victims of a 'race card.' -
I didn't think it could get dumber than Bush, but here we are.
-
President Donald ? .
-
I didn't think it could get dumber than Bush, but here we are.
Trumpito actually makes me feel ashamed of myself for how I felt about Bush -
WTF does Andrew Jackson have to do with the civil war?
-
"Why couldnt the blacks just, you know, just STOP being slaves? " - Trump next week, probably.
-
It's one thing to not know ? ... but he one of them aggressively stupid people. Almost like he say ? ? on purpose
-
Trump reppin for all the retards world wide
-
WTF does Andrew Jackson have to do with the civil war?
he doesn't kno.
jus like @Sandinista said Trump NO ? , prolly jus over heard someone mention Andrew Jackson. so now he is trying to impress ppl with his knowledge of American history.
Dude is a functional ? . -
I didn't think it could get dumber than Bush, but here we are.
someone on Twitter put it pretty well.
"Bush was a bad president. But he was still an actual President. Trump can't even be that." -